Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tim Rouse's avatar

It's a surprise, and a bit of a disappointment, when Vittles pushes a right-wing, anti-tax narrative, especially when it does so without any consideration of the impact VAT cuts would have on already pressured public finances.

Don't get me wrong - VAT is ultimately a regressive tax, and the vagaries of what is and isn't standard-rated are confusing and contradictory. But it's also the third-biggest source of tax income for the government - £160bn/year towards public services. If you're going to talk about cutting that income stream to any meaningful extent, you have to ask: what tax rises to make up for it? It's easy to hand-wave that away as someone else's problem, but whether it's solved by cutting spending or by pushing up other taxes, that's going to have an impact on restaurant and hospitality owners, workers and customers.

Much of this article is special pleading for the restaurant sector. But as the historic overview shows, paying VAT is just a cost of business for restaurants - the rate has been at least 15%, usually 17.5%, since the expansion of the sector in the 90s. It was only during Covid, a period which naturally hit the hospitality sector particularly hard, that it was, temporarily, lower. A business that can't pay its tax bill isn't a viable business - cutting tax rates for a sector is just a hand-out to the business owners from the public purse.

So reform VAT, yes. But unless it comes with a clear route to maintain public revenues, a VAT cut would just be subsidising business owners at the cost of the rest of us (and a reduction of the competitive advantage currently enjoyed by small vendors under the £85k threshold).

Expand full comment
Anthony's avatar

Cut the rate of VAT to increase the profits of restaurants, particularly Anerican based and founded chains does not have the right optics and certainly not for a group like Vittles, that propounds a particular food philosophy, that is supported by many of its subscribers.

There are better approaches to support the food culture that many of the subscribers would support. Indeed, perhaps it is a campaign that Vittles should consider focusing on.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts